Apple A16 vs Snapdragon 8 Plus Gen 1

Apple has launched the iPhone 14 Pro featuring their brand new SOC, the A16. See how well it fares against the SnapDragon 8+ Generation 1 Posted by erwinkarim on 3:41 PM, September 26, 2022 Last updated on 4:02 PM, September 30, 2022 Filed in: a16, snapdragon, apple, 8 Gen 1, 8 Plus Gen 1, mobile processors, comparison,

Another year, another iPhone is revealed and Apple makes a few hundred billion dollars. But behind a stellar product lies stellar engineering to make the iPhone one of the most beautifully engineered products in human existence. And like every year, Apple reveals a new processor running in the iPhone that makes magic things happen at the palm of your hand.

But how does it fare against the competition? As we all know, you always have to be on the move in the tech industry, otherwise you’ll be left behind. And this goes for the hottest product in the industry: the smartphone. And the contenders are Apple and Android. With the competition heating up, every year we see new products that attempt to leapfrog the leader of the race. And for so long, it’s been a two-way race: Apple A-series chip and Qualcomm SnapDragon series. This time, comes from the two flagship, the A16 Bionic and the SnapDragon 8+ Generation 1.

Apple A16 Bionic


The A16 powers Apple's flagship phone, the iPhone 14 Pro and it's bigger brother, the 14 Pro Max.

Usually, Apple would release a new SOC and put it on their latest phone and showcase their engineering superiority by showing what the latest iPhones can do for you. This year, things are different and might be the shape of the things to come


Apple has huge confidence in their SOC that they only put the latest one in the iPhone 14 Pro line instead of every new phone.

The new A16 chip is introduced but it is only put on the higher end iPhone 14 Pro. The mainstream iPhone 14 gets last year’s A15 chip (albeit it’s the one that they put on the iPhone 13 Pro) and a few upgrades. The lion’s share of new features goes to the Pro phones and we expect the gulf of feature differentiation would go wider next year.

The A16 Bionic features a 4nm manufacturing process instead of the 5nm of the A15 Bionic. 1nm might not sound like a lot. It’s just 2-3 gold atoms line up side by side. But at nanoscale, 1nm is at least a 20% size reduction. There’s also some speculation that 4nm by TSMC is not really 4nm, but an improved 5nm process where some of the features are 4nm.

General design, the A16 Bionic is a revised version of the A15 Bionic, which itself is a revised version of A14 Bionic and so on and so forth. This is a normal trend in tech where incremental improvements are introduced at every version, but if you compare from then and now, it’s like a quantum leap.


The block diagram of the A16. This design is scaled up to power the future M3 base and professional desktop SOC.

The A16 Bionic, like the A15 Bionic features 6 compute cores: 2 performance and 4 efficiency, 5 graphic cores and 16 Neural cores:. There’s also a Display engine which helps the iPhone handle ProRes video. The Display engine has also has been updated to include the “Photonics Engine* which handles the new 48MP camera sensor and also handles Apple’s new ProRAW file format. With each ProRAW file being around 25MB, yes not huge but not small, having a dedicated hardware solution will make things a lot smoother.

Yes, the overall layout looks the same as last year or the year before, but with new manufacturing processors, better optimization and overall higher clock speed bumps up the performance even more. With a smaller feature size, Apple managed to pack 16 billion transistors, compared with the A15’s 15 billion transistors.

Qualcomm SnapDragon 8+ Gen 1


SnapDragon 8 Gen 1 features. The 8+ has almost identical features but with slightly tweaked performance.

The SnapDragon 8+ Generation 1 is Qualcomm’s flagship processor. It’s meant to power the mobile phone company’s flagship products. For example,Samsung,one of the largest android phone companies in the world, uses the SnapDragon 8+ Gen 1 on their flagship: the Galaxy Fold4. So from there, the chip is no slouch.

Overall design improves upon the design that was introduced in SnapDragon 888. The Snapdragon 8 is where they started using the 4nm manufacturing process, ARMv9 (even Apple haven’t used this yet) and bump up the clock speed. The SnapDragon 8+ pushes this further by having a large cache and bumping further the clock speed for both the CPU and GPU while maintaining battery life.

The design of SnapDragon shows the difference in mindset between Qualcomm and Apple. Just like Intel, Qualcomm is a chip merchant with many customers with varied needs and wishlists. Apple, on the other hand, designs their own chips and has a vision of how things will work together in the present and the future. So Qualcomm, in trying to meet the needs of various customers tends to build chips in a broad brush which independently develops each component.


Samsung's flagship phones, the Galaxy Fold4 and Flip4 uses Qualcomm SnapDragon 8+ Gen 1

In the end the result is you have a different division producing different products, like a division that focuses on graphics, another on security, another on AI workload and another on the basic compute circuits. Each of the components are then spliced together to create a System on Chip to be used on smartphones, ranging from budget cheap smartphones to flagships like the Galaxy Fold4.


Block diagram of the SD 8+ Gen 1 shows a glimpse of the thinking behind the chip merchant. One would argue that each division is responsible for a core feature of a chip and they are mix-and-match to suit a particular need.

The SnapDragon 8+ Gen 1 has three levels of compute cores: 1x “Prime” core, 3x performance cores and 4x efficiency cores. For AI workloads, Qualcomm claimed a 20% performance/watt over its predecessor . Graphics is supported by a Adreno 730 core which is said to have a 30% boost against previous generation Adreno 660 which was on the SnapDragon 888. Unlike Apple, Qualcomm has an integrated 5G modem in the SnapDragon 8+ Gen 1. As far as we know, Apple still uses Qualcomm’s own chips externally on the iPhone 14 series. Integration will provide some performance benefit because signals don’t have to travel as far to get things done.

Benchmark Results


Apple did not mention the name of the competitor, but being the most powerful adroid smartphone chip, all signs points to the SnapDragon 8+ Gen 1.

Apple's A16 still leads the pack in terms of compute performance...

Based on Benchmark results, Apple’s A16 Bionic is still the one to beat in terms of raw compute performance. Graphic performance is still on the SnapDragon 8+ like it was the trend for a few years before. What’s impressive is that a mobile chip like the SnapDragon can compete core-for-core with laptop CPUs like Apple’s M2. Shows are far from what tech has become.


SnapDragon has more powerful GPU, but that doesn't tell the whole story ...

Here’s some caveat about benchmarks: they don’t tell the whole story. Apple’s approach to chip design can make some benchmarks irrelevant. For example, Apple uses hardware acceleration to handle ProRes videos and ProRAW videos. It is a bad thing if the benchmark on graphics is not stellar when the benchmark does not trigger the display engine?


Quite interesting to see that a mobile chip have the same core-for-core performance as a laptop integrated chip like the M2.

And here’s another secret about mobile performance. The year on year improvements over the last decade has been so impressive

Conclusion

Apple is still the one to beat in 2022. Apple is still the one who shows what is possible with the ARM architecture, supposedly designed for power efficiency over performance. Not to say that Qualcomm is a slouch, but shows the work ahead of what Qualcomm needed to do to catch up to Apple.

Plug

Support this free website by visiting my Amazon affiliate links. Any purchase you make will give me a cut without any extra cost to you

Base Pro
iPhones iPhone 14 / iPhone 14 Plus - (Amazon) iPhone 14 Pro / iPhone 14 Pro Max - (Amazon)
Watch Apple Watch SE (Amazon) / Apple Watch Series 8 (Amazon) Apple Watch Ultra (Amazon)
AirPods AirPods (Amazon) AirPods Pro (Amazon) / AirPods Max (Amazon)
iPad iPad (Amazon) / iPad Mini (Amazon) iPad Air (Amazon) / iPad Pro (Amazon)
Laptops MacBook Air (Amazon) MacBook Pro (Amazon)
Desktop Mac Mini (Amazon) / iMac (Amazon) Mac Studio / Mac Pro
Displays Studio Display (Amazon) Pro Display XDR (Amazon)

Other Ecosystem Items

Share this article:

Related:

Qualcomm Snapdragon 8 Gen 1 vs Apple A15 and Apple M1

How will the latest SOC from San Diego fare against the best from Cupertino? A comparison between Qualcomm SnapDragon 8 Gen 1 against Apple A15

Macbook Air M2 vs Base Macbook Pro M1 Pro

A decent MacBook Air M2 config is $1,600. How does it stack up against the base 14-inch MacBook Pro M1 Pro?

How to Maintain Your Apple Ecosystem (the Apple Upgrade Guide)

The game is an ecosystem. Purchasing it will get you in the garden, but it takes some to stay in the garden
Tags: a16, snapdragon, apple, 8 Gen 1, 8 Plus Gen 1, mobile processors, comparison,